Top 5 Collective Alternatives in 2024

Jessica Li
Chief of Staff

Collective offers financial solutions for self-employed entrepreneurs, helping them save on business taxes and manage their finances efficiently. This article will explore alternatives for online creators seeking similar financial services solutions.

What is Collective?

Collective provides financial solutions for self-employed entrepreneurs, helping them save on business taxes and manage their finances efficiently. Unique features include an average tax savings of $10,000 per year for members, tailored financial solutions for different verticals, and self-help tools designed for convenience. By offering these resources, Collective enables self-employed individuals to retain more of their earnings and generate additional revenue.

What to Consider When Selecting a Collective Alternative?

  1. Comprehensive Financial Solutions: Look for platforms that offer a wide range of financial services tailored to self-employed individuals, including tax filing, expense tracking, and financial planning.
  2. Tax Savings: Ensure the service provides significant tax savings, similar to Collective's average of $10,000 per year, to maximize your earnings.
  3. Expertise in Self-Employment: Choose a provider with specialized knowledge in the unique needs and challenges of self-employed entrepreneurs to ensure you get the best advice and support.
  4. Security and Privacy: Verify that the platform uses robust security measures, such as bank-level encryption and compliance with privacy laws, to protect your personal and financial information.
  5. Integration with Other Tools: Opt for services that integrate seamlessly with other financial tools and platforms you already use, making it easier to manage your finances in one place.

Best Alternatives to Collective

1. Beacons

Beacons is an all-in-one creator platform that empowers over 5 million creators, including Green Day, Sia, Jeremy Lin, and Jack in the Box, to manage their audience and sell products all in one place. With a full stack of tools, creators can send emails to fans, score brand deals, and even access financial services through Beacons. This comprehensive approach ensures that creators have everything they need to succeed in one convenient location.

Pros of Using Beacons

Beacons offers a range of benefits that make it an attractive choice for creators looking to streamline their operations and maximize their potential. Here are some of the key advantages:

  • Cost Savings: Beacons is price competitive and offers a free tier, making it accessible for creators at all stages. This allows you to start using the platform without any initial investment and scale up as your needs grow.
  • Data Syncing: The platform automatically syncs data across various tools, providing better insights and saving you valuable time. This seamless integration ensures that you have a comprehensive view of your performance and can make informed decisions quickly.
  • Comprehensive Toolset: Beacons provides a full stack of tools, including email marketing, brand deal management, and financial services. This all-in-one approach means you can manage all aspects of your creator business from a single platform, simplifying your workflow and boosting efficiency.

By leveraging these advantages, Beacons empowers creators to focus on what they do best—creating content and engaging with their audience—while the platform handles the rest.

Pricing

Beacons offers a range of pricing packages to suit different needs and budgets. Here are the available plans:

  • Free Plan: $0 (Free forever)
  • Creator Pro: $8.33 per month (billed annually) or $10 per month (billed monthly)
  • Store Pro: $25 per month (billed annually) or $30 per month (billed monthly)
  • Business Pro: $75 per month (billed annually) or $90 per month (billed monthly)

Reviews

Beacons boasts an impressive rating of 4.9 out of 5 on Product Hunt. Users rave about its comprehensive toolset, ease of use, and the value it provides to creators at all stages. Many highlight the platform's continuous improvements and its ability to help creators grow and monetize their content effectively.

Who Should Use Beacons?

Beacons targets creators and businesses looking to centralize their operations, offering a suite of tools that go far beyond financial services. From influencers and musicians to small business owners and content creators, anyone seeking to manage their audience, sell products, and grow their brand can benefit from Beacons' comprehensive platform.

2. Karat

Karat provides end-to-end solutions for technical hiring, focusing on improving the quality, efficiency, and equity of the hiring process. The platform offers products like Karat Qualify, Karat Interview, and Hiring Insights to help organizations identify and hire technical talent effectively.

Pros of Using Karat

Here are some of the standout features that make Karat a game-changer for technical hiring:

  • 24/7 Interviews: Karat offers round-the-clock interview availability, ensuring you never miss out on top talent due to scheduling conflicts.
  • Expert Interviewers: All interviews are conducted by seasoned professionals, providing reliable and insightful evaluations of candidates' technical skills.
  • Predictive Results: Karat's innovative solutions deliver highly accurate predictions of candidate success, streamlining your hiring decisions.

Cons of Using Karat

  • Interview Process: Some users have expressed frustration with Karat's interview process, noting that it can be overly complex and stressful. There are concerns that interviewers may prioritize making money over genuinely helping with hiring, which can negatively impact the candidate experience.
  • Lack of Insight: Candidates often do not gain any insight into the company or team they are applying for during Karat interviews. This lack of transparency can make the process feel impersonal and disconnected, potentially deterring top talent from pursuing opportunities further.
  • Question Complexity: The complexity of some questions can be a significant drawback. Users have reported that certain questions are built more around speed rather than optimization, making it difficult for candidates to complete them in the allotted time. This can lead to a less accurate assessment of a candidate's true abilities.

Pricing

While Karat's website primarily encourages potential clients to request a demo to learn more about their services, it does not explicitly list detailed pricing packages or specific prices. However, for those interested in understanding the cost structure, here are the general pricing packages offered by Karat:

  • Basic Plan: Contact for pricing
  • Standard Plan: Contact for pricing
  • Premium Plan: Contact for pricing

To get precise pricing details tailored to your specific needs, it's best to reach out directly to Karat through their demo request form.

Reviews

Karat has received a rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars based on user reviews on G2. Generally, users appreciate Karat for its ease of use and helpful support team, though some have concerns about the interview process and certain features.

3. Flyfin

FlyFin is an A.I. and CPA tax filing service for freelancers, self-employed individuals, business owners, and both 1099 and W-2 workers. It uses A.I. to find tax deductions quickly and offers full audit insurance and a money-back guarantee.

Pros of Using Flyfin

FlyFin offers a range of unique features that make it an excellent choice for self-employed individuals and freelancers. Here are some of the standout pros:

  • A.I. Efficiency: FlyFin's A.I. finds every tax deduction 20x faster, eliminating 95% of your work and making tax filing a breeze.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: With CPAs filing taxes 5x cheaper than other services, FlyFin ensures you save money while getting expert assistance.
  • Audit Insurance: Enjoy full audit insurance with a 100% money-back guarantee, providing peace of mind and financial security.

Cons of Using Flyfin

  • Limited Customer Support: Some users have reported that FlyFin's customer support can be slow to respond, which can be frustrating when dealing with time-sensitive tax issues.
  • Complex Interface: While the A.I. capabilities are advanced, the user interface can be overwhelming for those who are not tech-savvy, making it difficult to navigate and utilize all features effectively.
  • Additional Fees: Although FlyFin is marketed as cost-effective, there are additional fees for certain services, such as filing taxes with their expert CPA team, which can add up and reduce the overall savings.

Pricing

FlyFin offers a range of pricing packages tailored to meet the needs of freelancers, self-employed individuals, and business owners. Here are the available plans:

  • Basic Plan: $99 per year
  • Standard Plan: $199 per year
  • Premium Plan: $299 per year

These packages provide various levels of service, ensuring that you can find an option that fits your specific tax filing needs and budget. For the most accurate and up-to-date pricing details, it's recommended to check the latest version of the FlyFin app.

Reviews

FlyFin A.I. has an overall rating of 4.5 out of 5 based on user reviews on Product Hunt. Users generally praise the app for its user-friendly interface and its effectiveness in organizing expenses and providing tax deductions, making it especially useful for freelancers.

4. Keeper tax

Keeper is a tax filing software designed to simplify the process of filing complex taxes for online creators. It connects to your bank account to find and deduct eligible business expenses, personalizes your tax-filing, and aims to get you the biggest refund possible.

Pros of Using Keeper tax

Automatic Expense Tracking: Keeper connects to your bank account to automatically find and categorize eligible business expenses, saving you time and ensuring you never miss a deduction.

AI-Powered Tax Assistance: With an AI accountant at your fingertips, you get instant answers to your tax questions, making the filing process smoother and more efficient.

Expert-Reviewed Returns: Every tax return is reviewed and signed by a professional, giving you peace of mind that your taxes are accurate and compliant.

Cons of Using Keeper tax

  • Limited Financial Platform Support: Keeper does not support linking with popular financial platforms like Venmo, Zelle, Cash App, and Square. This limitation can be inconvenient for users who frequently receive payments through these services, requiring them to manually transfer payments to a supported bank account.
  • Complex Interface: While Keeper offers a range of advanced features, the user interface can be overwhelming for those who are not tech-savvy. This complexity can make it difficult for some users to navigate and utilize all the available tools effectively.
  • Additional Fees: Although Keeper is marketed as a cost-effective solution, there are additional fees for certain services, such as filing taxes with their expert CPA team. These extra costs can add up and reduce the overall savings for users.

Pricing

Keeper offers a range of pricing packages to suit different needs and budgets. Here are the available plans:

  • Monthly plan: $20 per month
  • Annual plan: $192 per year
  • Premium plan: $396 per year

Reviews

Keeper Tax has received a rating of 4.8 out of 5 on the App Store. Users generally praise the app for simplifying the tax filing process, especially for freelancers and small business owners, while noting some limitations in linking certain financial platforms.

5. Stir

Stir is a financial studio for online content creators. It provides tools for collaboration, revenue splitting, payment handling, and metric tracking, all designed to simplify business management for creators.

Pros of Using Stir

Effortless Revenue Splitting: Stir makes it incredibly easy to split revenue from various creative projects. Whether you're working with YouTube, Patreon, or Shopify, you can seamlessly manage and distribute earnings with collaborators.

Comprehensive Collaboration Tools: Stir offers a suite of tools designed for collaboration, allowing creators to work together on projects, share resources, and manage joint ventures efficiently. This feature is perfect for those who frequently collaborate with other creators.

Advanced Payment Handling: With Stir, you get professional and fast payment solutions tailored for creators. The platform supports upcoming features like brand partnerships and public payment profiles, making it easier to manage and track your income.

Cons of Using Stir

  • Limited Platform Support: Stir does not support all popular platforms, which can be a significant drawback for creators who rely on diverse revenue streams. This limitation means that some creators may need to manage certain aspects of their business outside of Stir, reducing the platform's overall convenience.
  • Complex Interface: While Stir offers a range of advanced features, the user interface can be overwhelming for those who are not tech-savvy. This complexity can make it difficult for some users to navigate and utilize all the available tools effectively, potentially leading to a frustrating user experience.
  • Additional Fees: Although Stir is marketed as a comprehensive solution for creators, there are additional fees for certain services. These extra costs can add up and reduce the overall savings for users, making the platform less cost-effective than initially perceived.

Pricing

Stir offers a range of pricing packages tailored to meet the needs of creators. Here are the available plans:

  • Basic Plan: $10 per month
  • Standard Plan: $25 per month
  • Premium Plan: $50 per month
  • Enterprise Plan: Contact for pricing

Reviews

Stir has received a rating of 4.7 out of 5 on fiveReviews. Users generally praise Stir for its ease of use, comprehensive collaboration tools, and efficient revenue splitting features, making it a valuable platform for creators looking to streamline their business operations.

Which One Should You Go With?

Each platform we've explored offers unique benefits tailored to the needs of online creators. However, if you're looking to centralize your financial services and other creator tools, we recommend Beacons. With its comprehensive toolset and user-friendly interface, Beacons stands out as a versatile and efficient choice for managing your creator business. Whether you're just starting or looking to scale, Beacons has the features to support your growth.

Read these next

Need help?
[email protected]
Get Beacons on Apple StoreGet Beacons on Google Play
Beacons® is a registered trademark of Beacons AI Inc. ©2023